288 – Jonathan Eig of Chicago, IL, Father & Best Selling Author of Biographies On: MLK, Lou Gehrig, Muhammad Ali & Others
Our guest this week is Jonathan Eig, of Chicago, a journalist, best-selling author, father of two daughters and guardian.
Jon and his wife, Jennifer, have been married for 27 years and are the proud parents of two daughters: Lillian (20) and Lola (14) as well as Jeffrey (33) who Jon mentored from Jeffrey’s age seven through Big Brothers/Big Sisters before the couple formally became his guardian.
With a degree from the Medill School of Journalism at Northwestern University, he began his career at the New Orleans Times Picayune, then Dallas Morning News, Chicago Magazine, and the Wall Street Journal.
Starting in 2005 Jon published his first best-selling biography: Luckiest Man: The Life And Death Of Lou Gehrig. He went on to publish Opening Day: The Story of Jackie Robinson’s First Season (2007), Get Capone: The Secret Plot That Captured America’s Most Wanted Gangster (2010), The Birth Of The Pill: How Four Crusaders Reinvented Sex & Launched a Revolution (2014), Ali, A Life (2017), and King, A Life (2023).
Jon has also written four children’s books: ‘Lola Jones Book’ Series: Some Pigtails, Score For Imagination, The D.O.G. and Everybody’s Home.
That’s all on this episode of the SFN Dad to Dad Podcast.
Show Notes –
Email – joneig@mac.com
LinkedIn – https://www.linkedin.com/in/jonathan-eig-b287b15/
Website – https://www.jonathaneig.com/
Transcript:
Tom Couch: [00:00:00] Special thanks to Horizon Therapeutics for sponsoring the Special Fathers Network Dad to Dad Podcast. Working tirelessly to research, develop, and bring forward medicines for people living with rare and rheumatic diseases. Discover more about Horizon Therapeutics mission at HorizonTherapeutics.com.
Jonathan Eig: This one small decision that I made to step in and become big brother for this kid has, you know, just, you know, Had endless ripples of benefits for me and has enriched my life and enriched my daughter’s life. And, you know, long after I’m gone, they’re going to be, have this really wonderful relationship.
We extended our family. We were lucky to have two girls, but then to have a extra, like a bonus kid and such a wonderful one, you know, I talked to him every day. We work out together at the gym almost, you know, weekly. And my, Daughters have their own independent relationships with him. And now with his wife, my little girl, my 14 year old daughter just [00:01:00] adores Jeffrey’s wife and they’re developing their own friendship.
You know, they go out for tea together, just the two of them. And like, how beautiful is that? You know, like we’ve created all these new waves of love.
Tom Couch: That’s our guest this week. Best selling author, Jonathan Ige, who became a mentor, big brother, and eventually father figure to Jeffrey. It’s a heartwarming story and we’ll hear it this week.
We’ll also learn about Jonathan Ige’s numerous best selling books about Lou Gehrig, Jackie Robinson, and Martin Luther King, to name a few. Jonathan Ige is a funny and fascinating guy, and we’ll hear his story this week on the Special Fathers Network Dad to Dad Podcast. Now say hello to the founder of the Special Fathers Network and host of the Dad to Dad Podcast, David Hirsch.
David Hirsch: Hi, and thanks for listening to the Special Fathers Network Dad to Dad Podcast. Presented by the Special Fathers Network, a dad to dad mentoring program for fathers raising children with special needs. The Special Fathers Network Mastermind Group experience is the most comprehensive program [00:02:00] the 21st Century Dads Foundation offers.
Dads raising children with special needs meet virtually on a weekly basis and form meaningful relationships while sharing weekly wins, discussing books, and sharing heartfelt challenges. One of the highlights of the year is attending an in person weekend retreat. We’re launching 10 new mastermind groups in 2024 with 10 dads per group.
That means we’re only looking for 10 like minded dads in each community. If you’re a dad raising a child with special needs, we hope you’ll join a local Mastermind group and make the investment to become the best version of yourself. For more information, please see the show notes or simply go to 21stCenturyDads.org.
Tom Couch: Now let’s hear this incredible conversation between Jonathan Ige and David Hirsch.
David Hirsch: I’m thrilled to be talking today with my friend, Jonathan Ige of Chicago, who’s the father of three, a journalist and bestselling author, including biographies on Martin Luther King [00:03:00] Jr., Muhammad Ali, Jackie Robinson, and Lou Gehrig, as well as a series of children’s books.
John, thank you for taking the time to do a podcast interview for the Special Fathers Network. Thanks, David. Great to talk to you. You and your wife, Jennifer, have been married for 27 years and are the proud parents of two daughters, Lillian, 20, and Lola, 14, as well as Jeffrey, 33, who you mentored from his age seven through Big Brothers and Big Sisters and then formally became his legal guardian until his age 18.
Let’s start with some background. Where did you grow up? Tell me something about your family.
Jonathan Eig: I grew up in Muncie, New York, born in Brooklyn, moved out to the suburbs when I was like three. My dad was an accountant working out of the basement of our house most of the time, uh, taking care of small businesses in the community.
My mom was a housewife, a very active PTA mom, and later went on to become a state officer in the PTA, and active running a non profit program in the schools that taught parenting classes, actually. So, uh, when I was in high school, my mom was hanging around the halls [00:04:00] Teaching parenting classes to teen parents at the school because, you know, we had some kids who became parents while they were still in high school.
And there was my mom, you know, so I was, I guess the expectations were high since the, the person teaching the parenting classes was my parent. But I grew up in a, with two brothers, um, and a very happy, I was a very lucky kid.
David Hirsch: Well, thanks for mentioning that about your mom. She was ahead of her time. She was working with teen parents.
That’s what I heard you saying. That’s a woman after my heart, because I do have a big heart for these super young dads, you know, who become fathers inadvertently. Right? In most cases, they weren’t like planning to become fathers. And they’re not even mature. Like, the male brain is alleged to, you know, be fully formed at age 25.
And we’re talking about teenagers, people in high school. Yeah, I don’t think mine is fully formed yet, but I’m keeping my fingers crossed. Okay. So you mentioned your dad is a retired accountant. And I’m sort of wondering, how would you characterize your relationship with your dad?
Jonathan Eig: Well, you know, my dad was home every day [00:05:00] because he worked out of the office.
More often from the kitchen table, because he didn’t like being alone in the basement. I was really unusual in that respect. I was probably the only kid in the neighborhood whose dad was home every day, who came to every Little League game, every band concert, every, you know, tennis match when I was on the high school tennis team.
He was. Always around, always warm and loving, just a sweet guy. He would, we had to play catch in the, in the backyard when he was bored and didn’t feel like working anymore. So that was unusual. Now, you know, there are a lot of stay at home working parents, but back then it was pretty unusual.
David Hirsch: Yeah, well, I can identify with your dad.
Um, I thought I wanted to be a Big 8 public accounting partner. Uh, when I graduated from college and it took me, uh, four years of college accounting and three years of working in Big 8 public accounting to realize, oh, maybe that’s not me. But, uh, I did prioritize being present and that’s what I heard you talking about with your dad.
He was present, more so than most dads.
Jonathan Eig: Yeah, and just to tell you a little story, When [00:06:00] I was born, I was born April 26th and my dad’s an accountant. He was working at that point for a big firm in New York. I was born on a Sunday. My dad called and said, I’m not coming into work on Monday because my wife just gave birth.
And they were still busy doing the taxes, especially I guess the late filings and the extensions. And they said, well, we, you can’t take the day off. We’ve got a lot of work here. If you don’t come in today, you’re fired. And my dad didn’t go into work. He left his job as, you know, a new parent with a new home and a lot of financial concerns.
He just quit his job and he never went back to working in the city again. He just decided he was going to try to make it on his own as a solo operator.
David Hirsch: Yeah, well that’s a beautiful story. You’re the firstborn of your brothers, right?
Jonathan Eig: Yep.
David Hirsch: More conviction could you share with somebody than somebody who’s willing to quit their job to prioritize their family?
Jonathan Eig: Yeah. Uh, talk about an early lesson. That’s the lesson I got on the day one, literally day one on the planet for me.
David Hirsch: Yeah, that’s [00:07:00] amazing. So, um, any other important takeaways when you think about your relationship with your dad, a lesson learned or something you’ve tried to incorporate into your own fathering behalf?
Jonathan Eig: I mentioned that my dad was unusual, that he worked from home. He was also unusual in that he’s just. Like a puppy dog in terms of showing his emotions. And I think most of the men of his generation were not that way. You know, they were taught to be stoic and to not show their feelings. And my dad was just, and still is, thank God he’s 85.
He’s just a big. of Emotions, and he wears his heart on his sleeve, and doesn’t always know how to express himself, but the feelings are right there for you to see, and that was always a real gift. You knew where you stood with him. If he was mad at you, if he was proud of you, it was all right out there to see.
So is that something you’ve taken away that you’ve tried to incorporate or not? Yeah, for sure. I’m a very emotional guy. I’m a very sentimental guy. I’m sensitive. I don’t feel like I have to Prove anything by being tough or like [00:08:00] showing no feelings. I think I get that from my dad for sure.
David Hirsch: Excellent. So I’m thinking about other father influencers and I’m wondering what role, if any, your grandfathers played first on your dad’s side.
Jonathan Eig: Um, my dad’s dad died when I was five years old in a, in a hit and run car accident. I remember him. I remember playing with him on the rug. I mean, I remember when he died. But, uh, I didn’t have a relationship beyond that. And then my, uh, my mom’s grandfather was a foreman in a bra factory and, um, they moved to Puerto Rico when I was little too, so he could continue working in the factory after the factory was sent overseas.
So I didn’t see him that much. And then he started suffering from Alzheimer’s pretty early. So my main memory of him is shooting baskets in the front yard on our basketball court. And he insisted that foul shots were meant to be shot underhanded. And that was the only way to do it. And I’m still pretty good at shooting those underhanded foul shots.
David Hirsch: Well, I guess the good news is you do have a firsthand recollection of both your [00:09:00] grandfathers.
Jonathan Eig: Yeah.
David Hirsch: Even though one died, uh, very prematurely with the other. This sad hit and run situation. I can’t even imagine, right? He probably wouldn’t have been much more than 50 or 60 years old.
Jonathan Eig: That’s right. He was in his fifties.
Yeah.
David Hirsch: Any other father figures, men who might’ve played an influential role in your life, either as a young guy or perhaps as a young adult?
Jonathan Eig: Let me think. I’ve had some great teachers. My high school tennis coach was a really important. figure in my life just because he was this insane disciplinarian. I really came to respect him and I think he shapes a lot of my attitudes about work to this day.
I quote him all the time to my kids like, Coach Moncall would say, you know, get your ass out of that chair and go get it yourself. You know, he was a real inspiration for me. Because I was not a good tennis player, but I worked harder than anybody else on the team, I think. And, and that’s what it took to please him.
David Hirsch: Yeah. Well, thanks for sharing. It reminds me of a baseball coach I had in high school. This guy was a ball buster. Kirby Smith was his name. It’s his name. He’s still alive. [00:10:00] And, uh, he was very disciplined. I’m telling you, he, he was used to coaching at the college level and he was like back in high school.
And, uh, he held us to a very high standard. And even to this day, you know, I always double knot my shoes. If I have lace up shoes, and it’s a direct result of being on one of his teams. He said, if we ever have to stop the game because you have to tie your shoes, you’re out of the game. I love it. So
my recollection was that you took a BS in journalism from Northwestern University. And I’m wondering, where did your career take you? Where did you think your career was going to take you?
Jonathan Eig: Well, from the time I was 16, I went to work at my hometown paper in Rockland, New York. And, um, I just wanted to be a newspaper reporter from that moment on.
I loved it. I just loved having a notebook and being able to pull up at a crime scene or knock on someone’s door and ask for an interview. I [00:11:00] was a shy kid, so the notebook was my key, my, my passport to the world, you know? And I liked writing. So I just thought that I’d be a newspaper reporter forever.
That’s, that’s really all I ever wanted to do. And, um, I thought what could be more stable than the newspaper career? Newspapers aren’t going anywhere. That’s for sure. And, uh, it worked out pretty well for the first 10 years or so. And then the newspaper industry started to really shrink up, but I was lucky in that I, uh, Made the transition to writing books.
That was not part of any plan. I just, it just happened. And, um, it’s been a, it’s been a great ride because I’m still basically doing the same thing. I’m just taking my notebook out and doing interviews and writing stories, just much longer format now.
David Hirsch: So how does a young guy like yourself, uh, get his first, uh, journalism job down in New Orleans?
Jonathan Eig: Well, like I said, I started when I was 16 at my hometown paper as a clerk, just basically taking out the trash or typing up stories that other reporters called in or whatever they wanted me to do. And then I went to journalism school [00:12:00] at Northwestern. I got some internships in the summers and when I graduated, I just applied for jobs and got a job at the New Orleans Times Picayune in one of the suburban bureaus.
Back then, again, newspapers were booming. They had more money than they knew what to do with. They were opening, you know, bureaus in, in every suburb so that they could sell subscriptions, you know, at really every house on every block. It was easy to get a job. The only question was, you know, could I get to the New York Times or could I get to the Washington Post?
But, you know, figure, you know, you put in a few years first. In New Orleans, you move up to a bigger paper and maybe in, you know, my, my goal was, you know, in four or five years to get to a bigger paper. But I went from New Orleans, worked there for three and a half years to the Dallas Morning News. And then I met my wife and moved to Chicago and gave up the dream of making it to the New York Times because I was just going to follow her to Chicago.
I didn’t quite give up on the New York Times, but once I got landed in Chicago, I was happy here.
David Hirsch: Well, you went to work for Chicago Magazine and then ultimately the Wall Street Journal, which is not like a second tier paper by any [00:13:00] stretch.
Jonathan Eig: No, it was a great paper and it still is a great paper, but I got there, started working for the journal in 2000 and the paper was still booming and so thick.
I mean, it was like a phone book that had so many ad pages back then. I remember the editor saying to me once, we’re having a hard time spending our budget. We have too much money. And if I don’t spend it all, they won’t give me more next year. Uh, so those are the glory days, really. The last of the glory days of print journalism in America.
David Hirsch: Gotcha. You also had a little bit of a stint teaching, haven’t you?
Jonathan Eig: A little bit. I’ve taught here and there. I’ve taught one or two classes. at Northwestern and Columbia College in Chicago. And then I guest lecture. I still do that almost every semester at Northwestern.
David Hirsch: And what is it that you talk about there?
Jonathan Eig: Writing, mostly, you know, reporting, creativity, how to come up with story ideas. I just, you know, I enjoy. Talking to the young journalists. It’s especially today. If you want to be a journalist today, you have to really want it badly. So it’s exciting to see [00:14:00] that enthusiasm.
David Hirsch: Yeah, well your your point earlier was that the field of journalism has changed dramatically, right?
You know, there used to be all these papers all these outlets and It was easier to find a job then perhaps than it is today. Well, there might not be newspapers. There’s still a lot of ways that people are consuming their information. So it’s not like journalism jobs have gone away entirely. It’s just a totally different way of approaching that.
Right.
Jonathan Eig: Yeah, no question. We still need great reporters and we still need great storytellers. It’s just harder to reach audiences and it’s harder to reach broad audiences. You know, you can write for your niche audience and you know, if you’re a conservative, you can find a conservative audience. If you’re a liberal, you find a liberal audience.
But back then, newspapers reached the whole community and that’s rare today. I think it’s just a little harder. For young journalists to get a foothold in the business, but not impossible You know if my kid [00:15:00] wanted to be a journalist today, I would be nervous about their career opportunities But I certainly wouldn’t discourage him because I think it’s really important work.
David Hirsch: Yeah. Well, thanks for sharing. So you mentioned that you moved to Chicago because of your relationship with Jennifer. I’m sort of curious to know how did you meet?
Jonathan Eig: Well, she was a journalist too, and she’s six years younger than I am. We both went to Northwestern, but we didn’t meet in college. And then a friend of mine who was working with her said, Oh, you’d really like this girl.
Um, and you’re interested in a lot of the same kinds of stories that you’re writing about. You should at least talk like professionally, but I think, you know, it’s more than professional. I think you guys would really make a great couple. And, uh, I resisted for a long time because Jen was in Charlotte and I was in Dallas, like who needs a long distance relationship?
But finally I just agreed to call her and. Talk on the phone and we really hit it off. So we, we chatted on the phone for a couple of months and then met in person and then she moved to Chicago and we dated long distance for about a year. And then I quit my job and moved up to Chicago to see if we could make it [00:16:00] work.
And we’ve been making it work for 27 years now. And the rest is history.
David Hirsch: Okay, well, thanks for sharing. So, um, You don’t have any direct connection to the world of special needs, but you do have a unique relationship with this, uh, now young man, Jeffrey. So, uh, which predates being married and becoming a biological father yourself.
So, what’s the backstory on Jeffrey and how did you meet?
Jonathan Eig: When I moved to Chicago, I had a friend here named Craig, who was in the Big Brother program. And Craig was moving to Seattle and asked me if I would take over for him in the Big Brother program. Because I had been a Big Brother twice before, in New Orleans and in Dallas, so I knew how much work it was, and also that, like, enrolling was a big deal.
It was a process. I just said, I’ll find him and I’ll do it, but I’m not doing the paperwork. So I took over. I went to meet Jeffrey. He was seven years old at the time. So I just stepped in for Craig and started visiting Jeffrey every week and taking him to the ballpark, taking him to see Cubs games, taking him to play catch, uh, [00:17:00] shoot baskets, helping him with his homework.
You know, I’d see him once a week. You know, again, as I said, he was seven. Jen and I were still dating or we had just gotten married and then, um, just kept that going until he was 14. And then his mom passed away. And he had no other family and no place else to go. So at 14, Jen and I became his guardians.
He moved in with us. He moved in first when his mom got sick, stayed with us for about six months. And then when she passed away, um, we decided that, uh, we should keep him around. And at that point we had a baby, you know, we had just had a baby around that same year. So now we went from having a six month old to having a six month old and a 14 year old, which is pretty weird.
Um, not always a happy situation, but we. We got through the hard times. It was, it was definitely tough. Not only, I mean, I’m laughing about it now, but those first couple of years were really hard.
David Hirsch: Yeah. Well, what most impresses me about what you’ve shared, and I think it speaks to your character, is that you [00:18:00] didn’t just open your home, but you opened your heart to this young man.
And, uh, it wasn’t like, Oh, overnight, like you said, you met him when he was seven and he became his guardian at age 14. So seven years worth of experience. Before that formal relationship, uh, had occurred. And when you look back on those first seven years, I’m wondering, what was it that sort of kept you engaged or involved like you have been?
Jonathan Eig: That’s a good question. Even at age seven, and Jeffrey was a mess. He cried a lot. He was a, he’s this really overweight, lonely kid, single mom living in poverty. He had a heart of gold. You could tell it at age seven. He was just such a sweet, loving kid. He had this nasty cat that he’d found on the street.
That cat, his name was Lucky, hated everybody except Jeffrey. And Jeffrey just. [00:19:00] Gave his love to this, to this cat and no matter how bad the world treated him, no matter how often his mom was evicted, the kids at school calling him names because he was obese and because he owned like one pair of pants and he smelled bad.
No matter how bad the world treated him, Jeffrey just loved everybody. I mean, you just couldn’t turn your back on a kid like that.
David Hirsch: Were there some important decisions you made along the way, helping raise a young boy like this?
Jonathan Eig: Well, the hardest part was when he moved in. I went from being his pal, his once a week pal, to having to be a parent. Mm-Hmm. . And the friendship kind of ended. And that was hard because I had to discipline him now when he, when he screwed up, I had to ground him.
And Jen too, we had to check his homework every night and he was failing all of his classes and we had to [00:20:00] make him stay in and study and we hired tutors. And I can still remember he would go out in the back alley behind our house and throw the baseball at the brick wall. He has a rocket for an arm and I would really swear he was gonna put a hole in that brick wall He was so angry at the whole world I knew that I should go down there and play catch with him and I did sometimes but not all the time because We were mad at each other and we were mad at the world that took his mom and I was Having to be this disciplinarian now and our friendship was suffering for it.
Those were some hard times and I, and sometimes, you know, we’d yell at each other. I can remember times where we were like chest to chest and he was getting to be bigger than me by the time he was like 15. We’d be chest to chest, you know, and he’d say, you’re not my father. And I’d say, damn, right. I’m not your father, you know, but I’m going to tell you what you have to do anyway.
And it was rough. Um, we laugh about it now, but, uh, it was not pretty, you know, Was there a turning point? [00:21:00] Just time, you know, just time. He knew we loved him and I think that having a little baby girl in the house helped because that diffused a lot of the tension. My Lillian would just crawl up in his lap and come into his bed and wake him in the morning and that really took a lot of the tension out of it.
He knew that I loved him. He, you know, he had a seven year track record but it just took time.
David Hirsch: So what impact has Jeffrey’s situation had on your girls, your marriage or your extended family for that matter?
Jonathan Eig: Oh man, I could write a book. There’s a lot there. I mean, my daughters love him. And when they were little, and they would say, you know, My big brother is 18 or my big brother is 20 and the friends on the playground wouldn’t believe him.
You don’t have a 20 year old brother. You’re making him up. And then, and then he’d show up and he’s this giant with the muscles on top of muscles. And they’d be like, Oh my God. And he’d be like, hello girls. You know, like, uh, he’s like, he’s like, you know, Dwayne Johnson [00:22:00] on the playground when he shows up with his, you know, his tank top, but they just adore him.
Because it’s, you know, it’s a, it’s an unusual relationship. They never had to compete with him for attention and he has a car and he can like take them out to dinner and he’s got a credit card. So like, he’s like a super brother. Like almost like an uncle. Yeah, kind of right. That’s a good analogy. And you know, it was a test for Jen and me to take him in and we didn’t always agree on how to handle things.
So I think we felt like stronger as parents for having gone through this together and, and figured it out. Yeah. You know, our parents weren’t always excited about having this person in our house, like who is this interloper who’s, you know, it was weird at times, but I think we just felt like stronger as a couple for having had this thing drop in our lap and we handled it.
We did the right thing and we feel like we were richer for it, like our family’s richer for it.
David Hirsch: That’s fabulous. So what’s Jeffrey doing now?
Jonathan Eig: He just got married. [00:23:00] And, uh, we love his wife and he just became a chiropractor. So this kid who barely graduated high school, who never read a book, who basically, like, Charmed his way through Elmhurst College without ever cracking a book, meets this girl and the girl says, you know, I think you can do better than working as a personal trainer.
And he says, fine, I’ll, I’ll become a chiropractor. And he did. And, uh, and then they ended up getting married and it’s amazing. He’s just passed his last licensing exam and he’s starting practice as a chiropractor right now.
David Hirsch: That’s awesome. Thanks so much for sharing. Must be like a unexpected dividend, special dividend to use an investment analogy when you look back and reflect on this relationship over the last, what, uh, 26 years now.
Jonathan Eig: Yeah, I think about it that way a lot. I feel like, um, this one small decision that I made to step in and become big brother for this kid has, you know, just had endless ripples of benefits for [00:24:00] me and has enriched my life and enriched my daughter’s life and, you know, long after I’m gone, they’re going to be, have this really wonderful relationship.
We extended our family. We were lucky to have two girls, but then to have an extra, like a bonus kid, and such a wonderful one. You know, I talk to him every day. We work out together at the gym, almost, you know, weekly. And my daughters have their own independent relationships with him. And now, with his wife, my little girl, my 14 year old daughter, just adores Jeffrey’s wife.
And they’re developing their own friendship. You know, they go out for tea together, just the two of them. And like, how beautiful is that? You know, like, we’ve created all these new waves of love.
David Hirsch: Yeah, I love it. And, uh, just reflecting on this, had Jeffrey not been in your family, You would have been a minority and a sorority.
Jonathan Eig: I don’t mind that. I like the, uh, I like being around all the girls there. That’s no problem. But it was nice sometimes to have a guy in the house who would talk sports and, and lift weights with me. I do, I do enjoy that. [00:25:00]
Tom Couch: We’ll be back with more of the conversation on the Special Fathers Network, Dad to Dad Podcast in just a few moments, but first this quick message.
Please help 21st century dads gather research on families raising children with special needs by having them complete the Special Fathers Network Early Intervention Parents Survey. A link to the survey can be found in the show notes. As a token of our appreciation, each person, mom or dad, who completes the survey will receive a great dad coin.
Thank you. Now, back to the conversation.
David Hirsch: Well, let’s switch gears and talk about, uh, you being, um, self employed as an author. And under the banner of full disclosure, I’ve read each of your six books as they came out. I know the buzz is about the King Alife, the MLK book that came out earlier this year, but I think it would be helpful for our listeners if we talked briefly about each book in chronological order.
Are you okay with that?
Jonathan Eig: Yeah, sure. Got all day. So, [00:26:00]
David Hirsch: um, I don’t recall exactly how we met. But I’m going to guess it had to do with the publication of your first book, Luckiest Man, The Life and Death of Lou Gehrig, which came out in 2005. So it was your first book. And I’m sort of curious to know, how’d you pick your subject matter?
And why Lou Gehrig?
Jonathan Eig: It was a pretty spontaneous decision. You know, I’ve been a journalist and a writer for a long time, and I was reading Seabiscuit when it first came out. And I thought, man, what a great book. I wonder if I could write a book like this. The key is that it’s about a sports hero, but it’s not really about sports.
It’s about characters. It’s about underdogs. It’s about hardship. I was, I was having this discussion with Jen over dinner. I said, what I need is a sports story. That’s about something much bigger than sports. Like Lou Gehrig. I just, just like that, it just popped into my head. Lou Gehrig story is really about dealing with tragedy.
[00:27:00] It’s about finding out that you’re facing a fatal illness when you’re in your mid thirties. Everybody can relate to that. Everybody’s lost somebody before their time. I wonder how Garrig dealt with it. I wonder how he handled it when he found out he was ill. I wonder what, how that affected his family.
The baseball is just a little part of the story. It’s a really human story about the tragedy of dying young. And I just thought I could write that book. I think I could figure out how to write it. I’d never written a book, but I think I could figure out how to do that. And I started. The moral of the story really is I gave myself permission to do it.
Like I didn’t say, well, I’m not a sports writer or I’m not a biographer or I don’t have a book agent. Like, I just thought it’s a really good idea. I should do it and I’m going to try. And if, if somebody tells me I can’t do it, all right, I guess I’ll stop. But until then I’m going to just try. And um, that was the key.
If, you know, if I hadn’t made that decision to just try and see what happened, then I don’t know, hey, my career would [00:28:00] have gone a very different path.
David Hirsch: What was the reaction when the book came out?
Jonathan Eig: It was really amazing and I’m really lucky because I, I, I don’t, I didn’t know that, how important it is for your first book to sell well.
But because I had lots of new information, I found letters that Garrig wrote as he was dying. So there was a lot of new material in this book. It really showed him an important new light. Yankee fans lined up to buy it. People with ALS or people who had family members who had suffered from ALS were interested in it.
It got good reviews and it sold really well. It made the bestseller list. And my, I remember my agent calling me and saying, you know, you’ve got it now. You’re established. Like you can do more books. You can keep doing this if you want to. And he was really excited, because I guess, you know, that doesn’t happen.
Most people, if they’re lucky enough to write a book, it’s rare to have that kind of commercial success, especially on your first one, so I was very lucky. I’m gonna call you the second luckiest man in the world, then.
David Hirsch: Yeah, right. Behind your subject matter. Okay, well, let’s go to [00:29:00] book number two, which came out in 2007, Opening Day, the Story of Jackie Robinson’s First Season.
Another baseball book. So you’re a baseball guy, right?
Jonathan Eig: Because the book sold well and because I enjoy doing it so much, my editor really encouraged me to do another baseball book. And I said, I don’t want to do a baseball book unless it’s about something bigger than baseball. It has to be about something more.
And I thought, what’s the biggest, most important story in all of baseball? It’s Jackie Robinson. I think he’s the most important player in baseball history because he changed the nation. There was already a pretty good Jackie Robinson biography out there, but I thought if I just focused on his first season, I could really capture his importance in a way that makes for a much more compelling story.
You don’t have to read the whole life. You can just get a sense for how he changed the country in the moment. So I wrote about his rookie season. Was Carl Erskine part of that? Do you remember? Yeah, he’s one of the guys I interviewed. You know, he’s still alive. Yeah, he’s the last of the [00:30:00] Dodgers of that era who’s still alive, I think.
David Hirsch: Yeah, he has a young son by the name of Jimmy, actually. Sadly, Jimmy just passed away earlier this year. He had Down syndrome. And for different reasons, you know, Jackie changed the face of baseball, literally. And, uh, Carl Erskine, you know, sort of alongside, you know, him as one of his closest friends, also changed the way that people think about disability.
And I think that, uh, there was this, uh, compassion all around with both those individuals, bigger than life people.
Jonathan Eig: Yeah. And Robinson, um, I didn’t get into this too much because the book was only about 1947, but you know, he had a son, a veteran and who, um, suffered from substance abuse problems and, um, that deeply affected Robinson’s life.
He lost his son in a car accident. At a very early age. And I think Robinson never really recovered from that himself.[00:31:00]
David Hirsch: So the third book, you went in a completely different direction and the title of which, uh, came out in 2010 is Get Capone, the secret plot that captured America’s most wanted gangster. How in the world did you come up with writing about Al Capone?
Jonathan Eig: Well, I didn’t want to do another baseball book because then I’d be a sports guy and I would never be able to break out of that.
So I’m, you know, live in Chicago and Capone is everywhere here. We’re still obsessed with him and I began thinking, you know Who’s the real hero of the Capone story is it’s not Elliot Ness. It’s the lawyers It’s the government officials who went after him and I was lucky to find The papers of the man who prosecuted Capone, thousands of pages of his papers including, you know wiretaps of the Capone gang and all this really cool stuff that had never been used before by writers and I wanted to tell the real story of Capone.
It’s really my only book that’s not about heroes. So it’s it’s [00:32:00] definitely the the odd duck in my row of books.
David Hirsch: So, uh, the fourth book which came out a few years later was 2014, The Birth of the Pill, How Four Crusaders Reinvented Sex and Launched a Revolution. Way different from the first three books.
Jonathan Eig: Yeah. My wife was urging me to write a book for women, because women buy more books than men, so she’s very practical. I heard my rabbi give a sermon about the power of man to change the world. Man and women to change the world. And he said that he thought the birth control pill might be the most important invention of the 20th century.
And I realized I had no idea how it was invented or who invented it. And when I looked into it, the story was just amazing because, you know, birth control was illegal in 30 states and they couldn’t get any government support, any university support. The inventors were these radicals who were, you know, doing it underground.
And it’s just a tremendous story of, of underdogs. Trying to change the world and [00:33:00] succeeding.
David Hirsch: Yeah. Well, it certainly has, um, revolutionized not only things here in the US, but around the world. So let’s switch to, uh, talking about Ali Alife that came out in 2017 and Ali died in 2016, June of 2016. And did you have a chance to meet him before he passed away?
Jonathan Eig: Yeah, I met him briefly. You know, I tried to get interviews with him and he couldn’t do interviews anymore. He was suffering from Parkinson’s and from dementia. Yeah. and he hadn’t done an interview in 10 or 15 years, but I went to his house and um, and got to meet him. And, um, I told him I was writing this book and that I would love to talk to him.
And, um, when I got done meeting him, his wife said, Mohammed wants you to come back and read him the book as soon as you finish writing it. And, uh, I said, I would love to, but he passed away before I finished. So I did not get the chance to read him the book. I don’t know if I, if I could have done it, it would have been, I would have been too nervous, I think, to read the whole thing to him.
Well, it’s a, it’s a big book. [00:34:00] Yeah. It would have taken a while and I’d be nervous about the parts he wouldn’t like, cause there were some things in there that he probably didn’t, didn’t want to hear, and even at the age of 70, something with Parkinson’s, he probably still could have kicked my butt.
David Hirsch: Was there a person that played an influential role in writing the book on Ali?
Jonathan Eig: Oh, there were many people. I mean, I interviewed all three of his living wives. His first wife had passed away. And they were incredibly important to helping me understand Ali. And they were very generous in sharing their time and their memories. Um, I get to meet Ali’s brother and spend quite a bit of time with him.
Hearing about Ali’s life. How Ali grew up and what his, what his childhood was like. So the beauty of that book was that there were so many people, hundreds of people around who knew Ali well. And I interviewed all of them. You know, usually I’m writing about people who are much older, you know, Ali, like Garrig and Capone and even Martin Luther King.
King, I interviewed probably a couple hundred people. Uh, but with Ali, I think I interviewed five or six hundred people. It was just amazing to [00:35:00] be able to spend that much time with people who knew him well.
David Hirsch: Yeah, well, thanks for sharing. It was an amazing book as well. So let’s talk about the most recent book, which came out earlier this year, entitled King Alife, about Martin Luther King Jr.
Fairly audacious undertaking, really. Dozens of books on MLK, a lot of material already out there. Where does one start embarking on such a project?
Jonathan Eig: Well, I had the idea that we have really, Lost sight of King as a person, as a, as a leader. We’ve turned him into a holiday and a monument and this very sort of stick figure approach to him.
You know, we talk about, I have a dream and that’s all anybody knows. I wanted to write a book that made him more human, that reminded us that he was flesh and blood, that he had failures, that he had doubts, that he had struggles with his own mental health. So I began just by interviewing people who knew him.
You know, I realized that the time was running short for that, that really this was the last opportunity to write a book that had access to the people who knew King, people who knew [00:36:00] him really well, like Andrew Young and Harry Belafonte and John Lewis, but also neighbors, kids he grew up with, um, his barber.
So I just, I just covered, you know, the whole country. Before COVID hit, I went and interviewed everybody I could who knew King. And then when COVID hit, I just kept interviewing them over the phone. And I felt like What a privilege. This is a man who will be remembered for hundreds of years, somebody who’s as important as, you know, George Washington and Abraham Lincoln to this country’s history.
And I had the chance to, to interview his friends and his family. Like, what a, what an unbelievable privilege.
David Hirsch: Well, I remember it was, uh, back in, I think 2015, if I remember. I think I introduced you to John Bellamy with the idea that he might be a good, uh, stepping stone to Dick Gregory. And I’m wondering, was that a lead that led to anything, or not necessarily?
Jonathan Eig: Yeah, no, Gregory was one of my favorite interviews. I’ll never forget, he said to me, What’s the [00:37:00] difference between Martin Luther King and Jesus? And I thought, is this a joke? You know, he’s a comedian, right? So I just said, I don’t know, what’s the difference between Martin Luther King and Jesus? And he said, videotape.
We’ve got videotape of Martin Luther King. And. I thought that is important. That is absolutely right. And it’s important to remember that we have documentary evidence and we have better than videotape. We have people who knew him. So that kind of fueled my mission.
David Hirsch: Any surprises along the way, you know, as you were interviewing these hundreds and hundreds of people.
Jonathan Eig: Oh, so many, so many surprises. You know, they just. They knew King and they wanted me to understand what it was like to be around him. You know, what’s it like to be in the room? What’s it, you know, what are these, I remember I asked his lawyer friend, Fred Gray, what did, what did King smell like? And he said, are you kidding me?
Like, who asks that? You know, what did he smell like? I said, yeah, I want you to think about it. What did he smell like? He said, I have no idea what he smelled like. He was Martin Luther King. Come on. Think [00:38:00] about it. And he thought about it for a while. He said. Cigarettes. He smoked, you know, like cigarettes.
Uh, but okay. So that’s good. But the, the big surprises were just to hear how he was just a guy, he was struggling. He, he had doubts. He really thought that like, after a while, nobody was listening to him anymore. You know, how sad is that, that, you know, Martin Luther King felt that people were getting tired of hearing him and that his message wasn’t getting through anymore.
It’s a great reminder to all of us that he didn’t give up. He never gave Abandoned what he believed in, you know, he could have compromised. He could have said, I’m going to just going to go teach for a while. This activism stuff is too hard. I’ll let the younger cats take over from here. I’m just going to go teach at Harvard.
Nah, he was right out on the front lines all the way to the very end. Where was he at when he died? He was in Memphis for a sanitation workers strike, you know, like he did not have to be there. His own people were telling him that it’s not that important. They don’t need you. You know, you got bigger things to worry about.
No way, man. He’s on the front lines for the. Working poor who needed his help.
David Hirsch: [00:39:00] Yeah. Well, uh, I think one of the takeaways that I got from the book was the emphasis on the fact that he was a Reverend Martin Luther King.
Jonathan Eig: Yeah.
David Hirsch: And you were talking about, uh, faith. You didn’t mention the word faith, but I think that’s what came to mind, which is questioning or doubting himself.
And I think what he was able to rely on, this is again, my takeaway from your writing was his faith, his deep faith in the purpose of the calling that he had.
Jonathan Eig: Absolutely right. And I say this all the time that when people ask me what made it possible for him to do what he did, I say Jesus, you know, his religion, his faith in God that made it essential, made it necessary for him to do this.
So that’s why he couldn’t take an easy route, couldn’t take the exit ramp, because he believed in what the Bible taught him. Has to say about our responsibilities to one another and he took that really seriously.
David Hirsch: It’s not lost on me that you’re a Jewish white guy writing about one of the most influential Black [00:40:00] Americans in our history.
I’m wondering What challenges if any did that impose?
Jonathan Eig: Well I’m one of a white Jewish guy writing about the most influential black Christian and Arguably the most influential black Muslim in this country, and I think it just requires more work You More modesty, more humility. You know, I approach these subjects knowing that I have to work harder to Earn the right to tell these stories.
And that doesn’t mean I’m the only one, you know, we should have black biographers writing these stories too, but this is my taking my shot at it and I just have to really work hard. And I, I, that’s why I sought the support and the help of all of these other people who knew King as well as black historians and black writers.
You know, I went to them and said, will you help me do this? And um, I think that made it possible for me to overcome my, my insecurities and my doubts, but you know, it’s, It’s a leap of faith to write anyone else’s life story. You know, if I were to write your life story or my [00:41:00] brother’s life story or Lou Gehrig’s life story, right?
What gives me the right? I don’t really know what goes on inside your mind or my brother’s mind or Lou Gehrig’s mind. I’m just gonna have to work hard enough to try to tell an accurate, honest story to the best of my abilities.
David Hirsch: Yeah, well to that point, um, at the end of the book there was a bonus interview.
With, uh, Larone A. Martin, the MLK Centennial Professor at Stanford University and one of the most well respected MLK experts in our country. And, uh, what a flattering conversation that was, the back and forth that the two of you had, because my takeaway was that he had the utmost respect for the work that you’ve done, especially uncovering a lot of things that had not been previously disclosed.
Jonathan Eig: There’s so many tapes. There’s so much information that’s being released. But I dug up a lot of new stuff that, that other scholars hadn’t come up with in part, just [00:42:00] because some time had gone by between my book and the one before it, like, um, decades had gone by. So there was a lot of new material. And I think that that helped to, uh, reintroduce King to show people, you know, that there was a lot out there they didn’t know.
David Hirsch: Yeah, well, it’s a must read. I just, uh, was taken by it. And, uh, I actually listened to the book on Audible and, uh, I thought that the narrator did a fabulous job.
Jonathan Eig: Yeah. Deon Graham is phenomenal. Um, I haven’t listened to it cause I can’t stand listening to my own words, but, um, everybody tells me they love it.
And I listen to little bits of it here and there just to get a taste, and I think he’s superb.
David Hirsch: So, not as well known, um, is that you’ve also, uh, authored four children’s books under what I would refer to as the Lola Jones book series, and the titles of which are Some Pigtails, Score for Imagination, the D.1.G., and Everybody’s Home. What’s the backstory [00:43:00] on these children’s books?
Jonathan Eig: Uh, the backstory is when my daughter, Lola Ike, was like, uh, I don’t know, six years old or something like that? She went through a phase where she wanted pigtails every day, and since I’m the one who gets up early in the morning to get the kids out of school, because my wife has a real job, I was the one assigned to make pigtails.
And I joked about it with her one day, because we were reading. Charlotte’s Web. I said, Hey, these are some pig tales. You get it? Some pig, like Charlotte’s Web, some pigtails, dad joke there. And, uh, and then when she was at school that day, I thought, Hey, I’m going to try to write a story called some pigtails.
Let’s just see what happens. And I’ll show it to Lola when she gets home. And I wrote something and, and I thought that’s kind of like, could be the first chapter of a, of a children’s book. I made it about a grumpy old man who doesn’t like making pigtails for his granddaughter, but does it anyway. And, uh, and, and I just had fun.
I just had fun writing it. And every day she’d come home and she’d read the, she wanted to know what happened next in the story. So I [00:44:00] ended up. Writing the whole book and then she made notes and gave me suggestions and, and I found a little local publisher that wanted to publish it. And then they wanted more.
So I wrote four of them and, uh, and they didn’t sell at all, but, but I’m, I’m, I love these stories and, and because it was a podcast. Something of a partnership with my daughter. Uh, I’m super proud of them.
David Hirsch: That’s fabulous. So any books that you started and never completed?
Jonathan Eig: No, there’s been books that I’ve researched that I thought I might want to write about something.
And then I gave up on it because it just didn’t feel right. Um, I’ve written a couple of novels, like big adult novels that I’ve never shown anybody that are stick in my desk drawer someday that I probably have shredded so that nobody finds them. Uh, but, um. No, uh, when it comes to the real work, I’ve been lucky that I’ve managed to publish everything that I’ve really written.
David Hirsch: So, um, what role, if any, has spirituality played in your journey?
Jonathan Eig: I think it’s [00:45:00] a hugely important factor for me. I feel like, I have a responsibility to do the right thing. It comes from maybe from being Jewish and raised with some kind of a faith, but also just coming from parents who taught me morality and taught me ethics and taught me the power of showing kindness and love to people.
I wouldn’t want to write stories or just have a job to make money. And I’m lucky that I can do something I love and get paid for it. Uh, but I feel really fortunate that I can, that I can tell stories and try to share other people’s stories. I think writing biographies, writing. Really any kind of story is itself an act of empathy and I’m, I’m, I’m, I’m very spiritual about that whole, about that part of it.
David Hirsch: Thank you for sharing. So I’m thinking about advice and I’m wondering what advice might you share with parents or specifically dads?
Jonathan Eig: Wow, I think it’s okay to show your emotions, even if those emotions are anger and frustration sometimes. That’s hard for me. Um, that’s been really hard for me. [00:46:00] Like, I think my dad gave me a great example of that, that he was, um, he really couldn’t hide his emotions. And I think I’m really lucky for that.
David Hirsch: I’m sort of envisioning your dad as like a, a light in a bushel basket. And he could not prevent the light from coming out from the bushel basket. I like that. Is there anything else you’d like to say before we wrap up?
Jonathan Eig: No, thank you so much for doing these conversations and for the work that you do to, uh, help us appreciate this.
Fatherhood and the joys and struggles of it. But, uh, it’s, it’s the best job in the world.
David Hirsch: I agree. If somebody wants to learn about your books or contact you, what’s the best way to do so?
Jonathan Eig: I’ll go to my website, JonathanEig.com and there’s an email button on there too. You can get, I think, everything you need there.
David Hirsch: Excellent. John, thanks for your time and many insights. As a reminder, John is just one of the dads who is part of the Special Fathers Network mentoring program for fathers raising a [00:47:00] child with special needs. If you’d like to be a mentor father or are seeking advice from a mentor father with a similar situation to your own, please go to 21stCenturyDads.
org. Thank you for listening to the latest episode of the Special Fathers Network Dad to Dad Podcast. I hope you enjoyed the conversation as much as I did. As you probably know. The 21st Century Dads Foundation is a 501c3 not for profit organization, which means we need you. With your help to keep our content free to all concerned, would you please consider making a tax acceptable contribution?
I would really appreciate your support. John, thanks again.
Tom Couch: Thank you, David. Take care. And thank you for listening to the Special Fathers Network Dad to Dad Podcast. The Special Fathers Network is a dad to dad mentoring program for fathers raising children with special needs. Through our personalized matching process, new fathers with special needs children can Match up with mentor fathers in a similar situation.
It’s a great way for dads to support other dads. To [00:48:00] find out more, go to 21stCenturyDads. org.
David Hirsch: And, if you’re a dad looking for help or would like to offer help, we would be honored to have you join our closed Facebook group. Please go to Facebook. com groups and search Dad to Dad. Lastly, we’re always looking to share interesting stories.
If you’d like to share your story or know of a compelling story, Please send an email to David at 21stCenturyDads. org.
Tom Couch: The Special Fathers Network Dad to Dad Podcast was produced by me, Tom Couch, thanks again to Horizon Therapeutics, who believe that science and compassion must work together to transform lives.
That’s why they work tirelessly to research, develop, and bring forward medicines for people living with rare and rheumatic diseases. Discover more about Horizon Therapeutics at HorizonTherapeutics.com.